Dividend Divergence: Yielding Insights From 2023’s Market Waves

This week, we delve into the intriguing dynamics of dividend stock performance within the S&P 500. Our analysis reveals a fascinating divergence between two groups: the 100 stocks in the S&P 500 that began the year without paying dividends and the 100 with the highest dividend yields. The non-dividend-paying stocks have markedly outperformed. Meanwhile, the high-yield dividend stocks lag with a modest average gain as of December 8, 2023. This contrast highlights the variable nature of stock performance and the importance of a nuanced approach to dividend investing.

The key takeaways as of December 8, 2023:

– Non-dividend-paying stocks in the S&P 500 surged by an average of 18.8% YTD.

– High-yield dividend stocks saw an average gain of only 0.81% YTD.

– Overall, the S&P 500 stocks are up by an average of 9.8% YTD.

– The two-year performance of high dividend yield stocks is roughly equal to non-dividend stocks, underscoring the importance of long-term investment strategies.

Our approach to dividend strategies extends beyond merely focusing on high yields. We prioritize a blend of above-average income and potential capital appreciation, targeting quality businesses with robust balance sheets, strong profitability, and solid industry positioning. This method aims to provide a prudent path to generating sustainable income and earnings growth. As we look toward 2024, our team is optimistic about the emerging opportunities, particularly given the resilience of economic growth and the attractive yields of many high-performing names in the S&P 500. Our commitment remains steadfast in guiding our clients through the complexities of the market, ensuring a balanced and forward-thinking investment strategy.

 
 

More from TWO THE POINT

  • Two the Point — Analyzing Recent Market Trends and Signals for a Strong Economy
    In our weekly video series, we highlight one observation we think is most important regarding the economy and the financial markets. This week we highlight the close relationship between the stock and bond markets and their influence on our economic outlook.
  • Two the Point — Unique Investing Opportunities Revealed
    In our weekly video series, we highlight one observation we think is most important regarding the economy and the financial markets. This week we discuss the contrasting narratives of the leading economic indicators and coincident economic indicators.
  • Two the Point — The January Consumer Price Index Report
    In our weekly video series, we highlight one observation we think is most important regarding the economy and the financial markets. This week we discuss the January Consumer Price Index report, highlighting its subtle complexities and the implications for future Federal Reserve actions.
WSFS Bank is committed to digital accessibility.